Research Misconduct

Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) does not tolerate research or publication misconduct and takes appropriate action when credible concerns are identified.

1. Definition of Research and Publication Misconduct

Research and publication misconduct may include, but is not limited to:

  • plagiarism and self-plagiarism;

  • fabrication or falsification of data;

  • manipulation or misrepresentation of research results;

  • inappropriate manipulation of figures or images;

  • duplicate or redundant publication;

  • simultaneous submission of substantially the same manuscript to multiple journals;

  • citation manipulation;

  • undisclosed conflicts of interest;

  • ghost, guest, or gift authorship;

  • unauthorized changes to authorship;

  • misrepresentation of author contributions;

  • unethical research involving human participants or animals;

  • failure to obtain required ethical approval or informed consent;

  • manipulation of the peer-review process;

  • misuse of confidential information obtained during peer review;

  • undisclosed or inappropriate use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools or AI-assisted technologies beyond basic language correction, editing, or formatting;

  • any other conduct that compromises the integrity of the scholarly record.

2. Reporting Suspected Misconduct

Concerns regarding suspected research or publication misconduct may be submitted to the Editorial Office of Scientific Works (SW AzUAC).

Reports should, whenever possible, include:

  • identification of the article or manuscript concerned;

  • a clear description of the alleged misconduct;

  • supporting documentation or evidence;

  • relevant references or other information that may assist the investigation.

The journal may consider anonymous allegations when sufficient and credible evidence is provided. All allegations will be treated seriously and assessed fairly, regardless of whether the person reporting the concern is identified.

3. Initial Assessment

The Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor will conduct an initial assessment to determine whether the allegation has sufficient substance to warrant further investigation.

Allegations will not be dismissed solely because they are submitted anonymously. The journal will distinguish genuine ethical concerns from unsupported, frivolous, or malicious allegations.

An editor who has a relevant conflict of interest in the matter will not participate in the assessment.

4. Investigation

When an investigation is warranted, Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) will:

  1. preserve relevant documentation and correspondence;

  2. evaluate the available evidence;

  3. contact the author or other individual concerned and provide an appropriate opportunity to respond;

  4. seek advice from independent experts where necessary;

  5. maintain confidentiality throughout the investigation, to the extent reasonably possible;

  6. manage conflicts of interest appropriately.

The journal will consider relevant COPE guidance and flowcharts when investigating suspected publication misconduct. Decisions will be based on the available evidence and the reliability of the research or publication concerned.

5. Institutional Investigation

Editors and publishers may not have the authority or resources to investigate all aspects of alleged research misconduct.

Where allegations concern the authenticity of research data, fabrication, falsification, serious authorship disputes, ethical approval, or other matters requiring institutional investigation, Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) may contact the author's institution, research organization, funding body, ethics committee, or another appropriate authority.

The journal may provide relevant documentation necessary for such an investigation, subject to applicable confidentiality and legal requirements.

6. Manuscripts Under Consideration

If misconduct is substantiated while a manuscript is under consideration, Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) may:

  • reject the manuscript;

  • terminate the peer-review process;

  • request clarification, supporting documentation, or correction;

  • suspend further consideration until the investigation is completed;

  • notify relevant institutions or authorities where appropriate.

The action taken will depend on the nature and seriousness of the misconduct and the available evidence.

7. Published Articles

If serious concerns arise after publication, Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) may take appropriate action, including issuing:

  • a correction;

  • an Editor's Note;

  • an Expression of Concern;

  • a retraction.

The appropriate action will depend on the nature, reliability, and seriousness of the evidence and its impact on the integrity of the published work.

Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and retractions will be handled in accordance with the journal's Corrections and Retractions Policy and relevant COPE guidance. Post-publication notices will be clearly linked to the original article to maintain the integrity and transparency of the scholarly record.

8. Whistleblowers

Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) respects individuals who raise genuine concerns about research integrity.

The identity of a whistleblower will be treated confidentially to the extent reasonably possible and consistent with the requirements of a fair investigation.

Good-faith allegations will be evaluated on the evidence provided, regardless of the identity or status of the person raising the concern. The journal will not tolerate retaliation against individuals who raise concerns in good faith.

9. Conflicts of Interest

Any editor who has a personal, professional, academic, financial, or other relevant conflict of interest concerning an allegation must disclose the conflict and recuse themselves from handling the matter.

Where an allegation concerns the Editor-in-Chief, responsibility for the assessment and investigation will be transferred to an independent senior Editorial Board member or an appropriate representative of the Publisher who has no relevant conflict of interest.

10. Cooperation with Investigations

Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to cooperate with legitimate investigations concerning manuscripts or articles with which they are associated.

The journal may request relevant explanations, research data, documentation, or other supporting materials, in accordance with its Research Data & Data Availability Policy.

Failure to provide reasonable clarification or relevant documentation may be taken into account when Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) determines the appropriate editorial response.

11. Protection of the Scholarly Record

The primary objective of investigations and post-publication actions is to preserve the accuracy, reliability, and integrity of the scholarly record.

Editorial actions will be proportionate to the available evidence and the seriousness of the concern. They are intended to correct or clarify the scholarly record rather than to punish individuals.

Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) will address suspected misconduct fairly, consistently, confidentially, and in accordance with its publication ethics policies and relevant COPE guidance.