Editorial Process
Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) follows a transparent, structured, and impartial editorial process to ensure that all submitted manuscripts are evaluated fairly and consistently in accordance with the journal's academic, editorial, and ethical standards.
1. Manuscript Submission
Authors submit manuscripts through the journal's online submission system in accordance with the journal's Preparing Your Manuscript guidelines.
Submitted manuscripts must comply with the journal's requirements concerning formatting, authorship, research ethics, declarations, and other submission conditions.
2. Initial Editorial Assessment
Upon submission, each manuscript is checked by the Editorial Office for:
-
Completeness of the submission;
-
Compliance with the journal's submission requirements;
-
Relevance to the journal's Aims and Scope;
-
Compliance with basic academic and ethical requirements.
Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements or fall outside its scope may be returned to the authors for correction or rejected at this stage.
3. Plagiarism and Research Integrity Screening
All submitted manuscripts are screened for plagiarism, duplicate publication, inappropriate text reuse, and other potential research or publication integrity concerns before being sent for external peer review.
The journal uses StrikePlagiarism software to screen all submitted manuscripts as part of its editorial assessment process.
The results generated by StrikePlagiarism are reviewed and interpreted by the responsible editorial staff. Editorial decisions concerning potential plagiarism or text similarity are not made solely on the basis of automated reports and remain subject to human assessment.
Where potential misconduct or significant textual overlap is identified, the journal may request clarification or additional information from the authors, return the manuscript for revision, reject it, or initiate an investigation in accordance with the journal's Research Misconduct Policy and relevant publication ethics guidance.
4. Editorial Evaluation
Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment and research integrity screening are evaluated by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor.
The editorial evaluation considers:
-
Originality and novelty;
-
Scientific significance and contribution;
-
Methodological soundness;
-
Relevance to the journal's scope;
-
Clarity of presentation;
-
Compliance with research and publication ethics.
The Editor-in-Chief or designated editor determines whether the manuscript is suitable for external peer review.
Manuscripts may be rejected without external peer review if they do not meet the journal's academic, editorial, or ethical requirements.
5. Peer Review
Manuscripts considered suitable for further evaluation are sent for double-anonymous peer review by independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise.
Each manuscript proceeding to external peer review is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers.
Authors may include their names, institutional affiliations, ORCID iDs, and corresponding author details in the submitted manuscript in accordance with the journal's Preparing Your Manuscript guidelines. The Editorial Office is responsible for preparing an anonymized version of the manuscript for reviewers by removing author names, institutional affiliations, acknowledgements, and other identifying information where necessary.
The identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to each other during the review process.
Reviewers are selected based on their relevant expertise and must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest. Reviewers with relevant conflicts must not participate in the assessment.
Further details are provided in the journal's Peer Review Process and Conflict of Interest policies.
6. Editorial Decision
Following peer review, the Editor-in-Chief or designated editor makes an editorial decision based on the reviewers' reports, the manuscript's scientific quality, and its compliance with the journal's editorial and ethical requirements.
Possible decisions include:
-
Accept;
-
Minor Revision;
-
Major Revision;
-
Reject.
The final editorial decision remains the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief or designated editor. It is not determined solely by an individual reviewer's recommendation.
Editors must disclose and appropriately manage conflicts of interest. An editor who has a relevant conflict must not participate in the editorial assessment or decision-making process.
7. Revision
When revisions are requested, authors are expected to submit:
-
A revised version of the manuscript;
-
A point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments;
-
An explanation of any reviewer suggestions that have not been followed.
Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or, where necessary, to additional independent reviewers for further evaluation.
The editorial decision following revision is made by the Editor-in-Chief or designated editor.
8. Final Acceptance
A manuscript is accepted for publication when the Editor-in-Chief or designated editor determines that it meets the journal's scientific, editorial, and ethical requirements and that all necessary revisions have been satisfactorily addressed.
Acceptance is communicated to the corresponding author through the journal's online submission system or official editorial communication channels.
9. Copyediting and Production
After acceptance, the manuscript undergoes editorial and production processing, which may include:
-
Language and formatting checks;
-
Reference verification;
-
Layout preparation;
-
Article metadata preparation;
-
Other necessary editorial and technical adjustments.
Authors may be asked to review the final version for accuracy before publication.
Any substantive changes after acceptance must be approved by the responsible editor and, where appropriate, the authors.
10. Publication
Accepted articles are published online as part of the appropriate journal issue.
Each published article is assigned a Digital Object Identifier (DOI), which is registered through Crossref.
Published articles are made freely accessible in accordance with the journal's Open Access Policy and the applicable Creative Commons license.
Article metadata and publication information are made available on the journal's website.
11. Post-Publication
The journal is committed to maintaining the accuracy, reliability, and integrity of the published scholarly record.
If significant errors, ethical concerns, or research integrity issues are identified after publication, the journal may publish a correction, Editor's Note, Expression of Concern, or retraction, as appropriate.
Post-publication actions are handled in accordance with the journal's Corrections and Retractions Policy, Research Misconduct Policy, and other applicable publication ethics policies.
12. Complaints and Appeals
Authors may submit appeals against editorial decisions in accordance with the journal's Complaints & Appeals Policy.
Complaints concerning editorial procedures, peer review, ethical matters, or other aspects of the journal's activities are also handled under that policy.
Appeals are reviewed independently by an editor who was not directly responsible for the original decision and has no relevant conflict of interest. Where necessary, an independent senior editorial representative or the Publisher may be involved in the review of an appeal.
13. Editorial Independence
Editorial decisions are based on the scientific quality, originality, relevance, validity, and ethical compliance of manuscripts.
Financial considerations, institutional affiliations, nationality, gender, religion, political views, or other personal characteristics of authors do not influence editorial decisions.
The journal's editorial process is conducted independently of commercial, financial, and other external interests.
Editors and Editorial Board members must disclose relevant conflicts of interest and must not participate in decisions concerning manuscripts where such conflicts exist.
Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief or Editorial Board members are handled independently by an editor who has no relevant conflict of interest and undergo the same peer review and editorial standards as other submissions.
Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) is committed to maintaining a fair, transparent, independent, and ethically responsible editorial process.


