Peer Review Process

Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) applies a double-anonymous peer review process to ensure an impartial, rigorous, and transparent evaluation of submitted manuscripts.

In the double-anonymous review process, the identities of both authors and reviewers are kept confidential throughout the peer review process. Reviewers are not provided with the names, institutional affiliations, or other identifying information of the authors, and authors are not informed of the identities of the reviewers.

All research articles submitted to the journal are subject to external peer review by at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise.

1. Initial Editorial Assessment

All manuscripts submitted to Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) undergo an initial editorial assessment before being sent for peer review.

The editorial assessment considers:

  • Relevance to the journal's aims and scope;

  • Originality and scientific significance;

  • Methodological soundness;

  • Clarity and completeness of presentation;

  • Compliance with the journal's submission requirements;

  • Ethical and publication standards;

  • Potential plagiarism or other publication ethics concerns.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's basic requirements or fall outside its scope may be rejected at this stage without external peer review.

2. Selection of Reviewers

Each manuscript that proceeds to external peer review is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise.

Reviewers are selected based on their:

  • Academic and research expertise;

  • Subject-matter knowledge;

  • Publication record and relevant experience;

  • Absence of conflicts of interest with the authors or the research.

Reviewers must be able to provide an impartial assessment and must not have relationships or interests that could compromise the objectivity of their evaluation.

The journal may invite additional reviewers when necessary, particularly when the evaluations received are substantially different or further expert assessment is required.

3. Double-Anonymous Review

Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) uses a double-anonymous review model.

Authors may provide their names, institutional affiliations, ORCID iDs, and corresponding author details on the first page of the submitted manuscript, in accordance with the journal's Preparing Your Manuscript guidelines. The Editorial Office is responsible for preparing an anonymized version of the manuscript for reviewers by removing author names, institutional affiliations, acknowledgements, and other identifying information where necessary.

Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of the manuscript and must not attempt to identify the authors.

Reviewers must not use, share, or disclose unpublished information obtained through the peer review process.

4. Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers are expected to evaluate manuscripts objectively, fairly, and constructively.

Reviews should address, where applicable:

  • Originality and significance of the research;

  • Scientific and methodological quality;

  • Validity of the results and conclusions;

  • Clarity and organization of the manuscript;

  • Adequacy of references;

  • Ethical considerations;

  • Suitability for publication in Scientific Works (SW AzUAC).

Reviewers should provide clear and constructive comments that can assist authors in improving their manuscripts.

Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest and decline the review when they cannot provide an impartial assessment.

Reviewers must not contact authors directly regarding manuscripts under review unless explicitly authorized by the editor.

5. Editorial Decision

Following the completion of peer review, the Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor considers the reviewers' reports and makes the editorial decision.

Possible decisions include:

  • Accept;

  • Minor Revision;

  • Major Revision;

  • Reject.

The final editorial decision is made by the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately designated editor and is not determined solely by an individual reviewer.

Where necessary, the editor may request additional reviews before reaching a decision.

6. Revisions

When revisions are requested, authors should submit a revised manuscript together with a clear response to the reviewers' comments.

The revised manuscript may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation.

The number of revision rounds depends on the extent of the revisions required and the editor's assessment.

7. Conflicts of Interest and Editorial Independence

Editors and members of the Editorial Board must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest relating to a submitted manuscript.

An editor or Editorial Board member who is an author or co-author of a submitted manuscript, has a close professional or personal relationship with an author, or otherwise has a conflict of interest must not participate in the editorial assessment, selection of reviewers, peer review management, or final decision concerning that manuscript.

Such manuscripts must be handled by an independent editor who has no relevant conflict of interest.

The journal ensures that all manuscripts, including those submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, editors, and Editorial Board members, undergo the same independent peer review process and editorial standards as other submissions.

8. Confidentiality, Ethical Conduct, and Use of AI

All manuscripts submitted to Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) are treated as confidential documents during the editorial and peer review process.

Editors and reviewers must not disclose information about submitted manuscripts or use unpublished material for personal or professional purposes.

Reviewers and editors must not upload confidential manuscripts or any identifiable or unpublished manuscript content to publicly accessible generative AI tools.

Generative AI tools must not be used to generate peer review reports, substantive reviewer assessments, or editorial decisions. Limited use of AI-assisted tools for basic language correction or editing of review reports or editorial communications may be permitted only where manuscript confidentiality is fully protected. Any such use must be disclosed to the responsible editor. Reviewers and editors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, confidentiality, and content of their reports and editorial communications.

Any concerns regarding research integrity, plagiarism, conflicts of interest, or other publication ethics issues identified during peer review may be investigated in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies and relevant guidance and recommendations issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

9. Reviewer Anonymity

Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors as part of the double-anonymous peer review process.

The journal does not publish reviewer names alongside individual articles unless a separate editorial policy explicitly provides otherwise.

10. Appeals

Authors who believe that an editorial decision was based on a significant factual or procedural error may submit a reasoned appeal to the Editorial Office.

Appeals should clearly explain the grounds for reconsideration and provide relevant evidence where applicable.

Appeals will be considered by the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately designated editor who was not directly responsible for the original decision, where feasible.

11. Peer Review and Publication Timeline

Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) aims to process manuscripts efficiently while maintaining the quality and integrity of peer review.

The initial external peer review process is expected to be completed within 14 days from the date the manuscript is sent to reviewers. The actual duration may vary depending on the availability of qualified reviewers, the subject of the manuscript, and the need for additional review.

The time required for revisions and subsequent review rounds may vary depending on the extent of revisions requested.

The journal does not guarantee acceptance or publication within a specific period. Authors will be informed of significant delays where appropriate.

Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) is committed to maintaining a rigorous, fair, confidential, and double-anonymous peer review process in accordance with recognized standards of scholarly publishing and relevant COPE guidance.