Complaints & Appeals
Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) is committed to maintaining high standards of editorial integrity, transparency, fairness, and professionalism throughout the publication process. The journal provides procedures for receiving, assessing, investigating, and resolving complaints and appeals concerning editorial decisions, peer review, publication procedures, ethical matters, and other aspects of the journal's activities.
All complaints and appeals are handled fairly, objectively, confidentially, and without discrimination, taking into consideration relevant publication ethics standards and guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
1. Scope of Complaints
Complaints may concern, but are not limited to:
-
editorial decisions or editorial procedures;
-
delays in manuscript processing or publication;
-
peer review procedures or reviewer conduct;
-
conflicts of interest;
-
authorship or contributorship disputes;
-
suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabrication, falsification, or other research misconduct;
-
breaches of confidentiality;
-
inappropriate use or disclosure of personal information;
-
ethical concerns related to published or submitted research;
-
inappropriate conduct by editors, Editorial Board members, reviewers, or journal staff;
-
concerns regarding editorial or publishing practices.
Complaints and appeals must be submitted in writing to the journal's official Editorial Office email address: [email protected].
2. Submission of Complaints
A complaint should provide sufficient information to allow Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) to understand and assess the matter.
Where possible, the complainant should include:
-
the title and DOI of the relevant manuscript or article, where applicable;
-
a clear description of the complaint;
-
relevant evidence or supporting documentation;
-
the names of the individuals or parties involved, where relevant;
-
the requested clarification or proposed resolution, where appropriate.
Anonymous complaints may be considered where sufficient and credible information is provided to allow the journal to assess the concern.
3. Complaint Assessment and Investigation Procedure
Complaints will be handled according to the following procedure:
-
Receipt and registration: The Editorial Office receives and records the complaint.
-
Initial assessment: The Editor-in-Chief or a designated editorial representative assesses the nature of the complaint and determines whether it falls within the journal's responsibility.
-
Conflict of interest assessment: The person responsible for handling the complaint must have no relevant conflict of interest and must not be directly involved in the matter.
-
Investigation: Relevant editorial records, correspondence, supporting evidence, and other available documentation are reviewed.
-
Right to respond: Where appropriate, the individuals concerned are given an opportunity to provide explanations or relevant information.
-
Independent advice: Where necessary, the journal may consult independent experts, relevant institutions, ethics committees, or other appropriate authorities.
-
Decision and notification: The responsible editor evaluates the evidence, determines the appropriate action, and communicates the outcome to the complainant, subject to confidentiality and applicable legal requirements.
The journal will handle complaints as promptly as reasonably possible and keep the complainant informed of significant delays or developments.
4. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they believe that the decision was based on:
-
a significant factual error;
-
a misunderstanding or misinterpretation of the manuscript;
-
a serious procedural irregularity in the editorial or peer review process;
-
a relevant conflict of interest that was not appropriately managed;
-
substantial new information that could reasonably affect the decision.
An appeal must:
-
be submitted in writing;
-
clearly identify the manuscript;
-
explain the specific grounds for the appeal;
-
address the reasons given in the editorial decision;
-
provide relevant evidence or clarification, where appropriate.
Appeals should be submitted by the corresponding author on behalf of the authors. An appeal should not simply repeat arguments already considered during the original editorial assessment.
5. Appeal Review Procedure
Appeals will be reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief or another appropriately designated editor who was not directly responsible for the original decision and has no relevant conflict of interest.
Where the Editor-in-Chief made the original decision, has a conflict of interest, or is otherwise involved in the matter, the appeal will be assigned to an independent senior Editorial Board member or an appropriate representative of the Publisher.
The responsible editor will review the original decision, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and the grounds and evidence provided in the appeal.
Where necessary, the journal may seek advice from additional independent reviewers or subject experts.
Following assessment, an appeal may result in:
-
confirmation of the original decision;
-
reconsideration of the manuscript;
-
additional independent peer review;
-
another appropriate editorial action.
The outcome of an appeal, together with the reasons for the decision, will be communicated in writing to the corresponding author.
The journal will handle appeals as promptly as reasonably possible and inform the corresponding author of significant delays or developments.
6. Finality of Editorial Decisions
Editorial decisions are made independently on the basis of the manuscript's scientific quality, originality, relevance, ethical compliance, and the journal's editorial policies.
An appeal does not guarantee that an editorial decision will be changed.
Once an appeal has been fully considered and a final decision has been communicated, the journal will normally consider the matter closed unless substantial new evidence or a serious procedural concern is subsequently identified.
7. Complaints Concerning the Editor-in-Chief, Editors, or Editorial Board Members
Complaints concerning the Editor-in-Chief, an editor, or a member of the Editorial Board must not be handled by the individual who is the subject of the complaint.
Such complaints will be referred to an independent senior Editorial Board member or an appropriate representative of the Publisher who has no relevant conflict of interest.
Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief or raises serious ethical or professional concerns, the Publisher may appoint an independent person to assess the matter.
8. Complaints Concerning Peer Review
Concerns about reviewer conduct, including breaches of confidentiality, inappropriate or discriminatory comments, undisclosed conflicts of interest, misuse of confidential information, or other unethical behavior, may be investigated by the journal.
Reviewers are expected to maintain confidentiality, provide objective and constructive assessments, disclose relevant conflicts of interest, and comply with the journal's Peer Review Process and Conflict of Interest policies.
Where reviewer misconduct is established, the journal may discontinue the reviewer's involvement in the manuscript and take other appropriate action.
9. Confidentiality and Protection Against Retaliation
Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) will handle complaints and appeals confidentially to the extent reasonably possible and consistent with a fair investigation and applicable legal requirements.
Information will be shared only with individuals who need it for the purpose of assessing and resolving the matter.
Individuals who raise legitimate concerns in good faith must not be disadvantaged or subjected to retaliation as a result of submitting a complaint or appeal.
10. Complaints Concerning Published Articles
Where a complaint concerns the integrity, ethical compliance, or reliability of a published article, the journal will assess the matter in accordance with its Research Misconduct Policy and Corrections and Retractions Policy.
Depending on the findings, the journal may publish a correction, Editor's Note, Expression of Concern, or retraction, where appropriate.
11. External Complaints and Institutional Investigations
Where a complaint requires investigation beyond the journal's authority or expertise, Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) may refer the matter to the relevant institution, employer, research organization, ethics committee, funding body, or another competent authority.
The journal may cooperate with legitimate investigations and provide relevant documentation, subject to applicable confidentiality and legal requirements.
12. Commitment to Fairness and Transparency
Scientific Works (SW AzUAC) aims to ensure that complaints and appeals are assessed objectively, consistently, impartially, and without discrimination.
The journal will maintain appropriate records of complaints, investigations, appeals, decisions, and actions taken.
All complaints and appeals will be handled in accordance with the journal's policies, applicable publication ethics principles, and relevant COPE guidance.


